It is ‘normally assumed’ that
making an entire college building air-conditioned would burden the students
with unreasonable increase in fees, but I am afraid – this is only a myth
created by those who love to exploit this ‘common sense’ by offering such a
justification for the huge fees that they charge from the students. As it might
be shocking to know that making all the classrooms & Labs of a college
air-conditioned would actually cost less than Rs. 500 per students annually!
I was driven to write this piece
when I came two know about the recent turmoil that Hindu College observed when
they decided to charge a hefty fees for their newly constructed Girls’ Hostel –
many steps more than what Boys are being charged. The justification offered in
support of this differential fee structure was that the new structure was
proposed to be air-conditioned.
Surprisingly, generally speaking,
it is a commonly established and accepted fact that an educational institution
that has air-conditioned class rooms can sustain its infrastructure only by
charging fees in lacs. I am here to break this myth. I would pick up the case
of my college that has around 5000 fees-paying students, around 50 class rooms
and approximately 20 labs. To start with, I can assure you that if I dump 150
air-conditioners in my college, the administration will face huge difficulty in
finding a place to install all of them (given that the college already has some
air-conditioners installed in the office and some computer labs). Now let me
place some basic calculations here. It would be perfectly realistic to assume
that purchase and installation (including cabling) will cost approximately 50
thousand per AC. Therefore the total cost of installation of these 150 ACs will
be 150x50,000=75,00,000. And thus, the cost incurred per student will be a
one-time contribution of 75,00,000/5000 = 1500 (Rs.). It is clear that we need
only a single contribution of Rs. 1500 per student to ensure air-conditioning
of the entire college building. Moreover, if our college decides to do this in
a span of three years, we need a contribution of Rs. 500 per student to achieve
our target in a time-bound 3-year time.
Now, another greater myth is on
the running cost of these ACs. Let me try to break this myth too. On an
average, our college can claim to have not more than 180-200 teaching days in a
year. And discounting the winter days when ACs are not required, we may need
these ACs in the class rooms only for about 150 days and that too from 9 AM to
5 PM (8 hours a day). This generous estimate makes these 150 ACs run for
150x150x8 = 1,80,000 hrs. On an average this would consume 2,70,000 units of
energy costing Rs. 25 lac maximum. This, when distributed on the 5000 students
would come to 25,00,000/5000 = Rs. 500 per student per annum! Given that
colleges are already charging a minimum of Rs. 10 thousand per annum from the
students, it is only a lack of vision that has pulled the college
administration back from making the campus air-conditioned. On the contrary,
colleges have often given an impression that air-conditioning the campus would
cost them fortune. Myth have got built up by the incident like Hindu College
that proposed to charge about Rs. 1,20,000 per student as compared to Rs.
80,000 per student primarily for air-conditioning. A whooping difference of Rs.
40,000 per students annually is not only ethically unjustified but that also
help create the ‘Myth’ that I have pointed out here. When AC can be for all –
it is conspiratorially being utilized with a motive to create and maintain a
division between an Elitists’ and a supposedly Commoners’ institution.
Let us break this myth and encourage
college administrations to think of ways to get the entire campus
air-conditioned. One must never forget that air-conditioned class rooms not
only can encourage attendance in the classrooms but it would also provide the
students the much-required comfortable environment during their tense, hot and
anxious examination days.
2 comments:
good analysis sir
Yes, air-conditioning of classrooms and lab is a economically sound proposal, but another calculation will be requires for hostel room where it may cost 40-50 times more per student.
Post a Comment